There is officially no right and wrong anymore.
Behaviour, beliefs, desires and preferences that were taboo, illegal, wrong, shameful
and condemned a mere 50 years ago are today accepted and even celebrated, with
Western society falling over itself to accommodate behaviour that not too long
ago would have had its proponents sectioned.
Witness the case of a man, Bruce Jenner, a 65 year old three-time
divorcee, father of six, step-father of four and soon to be grandfather; a champion
athlete, Olympic gold-medallist and world record holder who triumphed in the 1976 games in what is
hands-down the toughest contest of them all: The Decathlon. To be the best in
the world in 10 different competitions in a monumental show of athletic
prowess; to sire six children (three boys and three girls); to woo, win and wed
three beautiful women; raise four children that are not yours; be respected
amongst both your peers and the public who pay to hear you inspire them with
the power of your words and glean knowledge from your success; to remain
humble, loving and pleasant to both family and fans; to be law-abiding and free
from the common vices that often ruin your sex: womanising, drugs, gambling and
drinking – all these achievements to me speak of a man that has excelled as a
human being.
Bruce Jenner: The Olympic Hero
Bruce Jenner, to all intents and purposes, had mastered the
art of being a man.
So the fact that he has now begun the process of becoming a
woman because he feels himself to be in the wrong body is not only baffling to
the innocent bystander, but downright unbelievable. For how can someone who
feels he is not actually a man, succeed so well in both public and private displays of
masculinity? How on earth did his gender serve him so well if it was the wrong
fit from birth? If God and nature got it so wrong, why did he accomplish so
much as a man and succeed in feats ‘lesser’ men struggle daily to achieve?
Bruce Jenner: The man
If a gifted concert pianist who, for decades, thrilled
audiences worldwide with his accomplished compositions confessed later on that
he was blessed with the wrong gift, and in fact always had the desire to be an
excellent violinist, and actually felt awkward and ill-fitted to playing the
piano, would you not think that odd? How can you be so good at what you consider
wrong for you? And if you were truly meant to be a violinist not a pianist, why
didn’t fate lead you to a violin first and not a piano?
Can a girl be formed in the womb as a boy by accident? Or is
this condition purely psychological or spiritual and nothing to do with the
physicalities of gender at all?
The truth is that Bruce Jenner’s predicament, and that of
many transgender people around the world is still unfathomable not just to the
average person but to science, to religion and to common sense. It is a strange affliction
that cannot be explained adequately, yet the sincerity of their desire can be
ascertained by their determination to go through pain, ridicule, debt and broken
relationships in their quest to right what they feel is wrong.
So I am not suggesting that Jenner’s desire to change his
sex is not ‘real’, i.e. that it is superficial. For a man like him to go
through this public transformation, it must be real. There were already
sniggers about the desecration of his masculinity by viewers of Keeping Up With The Kardashians, the
reality TV show centred around his ubiquitous step-daughter Kim Kardashian, his
now ex-wife (her mother) Kris, Kim’s sisters and brother and his two daughters.
The show that brought him fame with today’s generation too young to remember
him as an Olympic hero often depicted him as a man of little importance in the
background, ignored and often the butt of jokes from the uber-beautiful,
hyper-feminine, financially powerful and assertive glamazons in his family, led
by the matriarch Kris who seemed to wear the trousers in their marriage.
Bruce with 'The Kardashians'
I proposed at first that all the strong female stimuli around him weakened his masculinity so that his wanting to be a woman was like him throwing in the towel; an ‘if you can’t beat them, join them’ admission of failure whereby his manhood was so thoroughly bashed that he in the end became effeminate to the extreme. His balls were handed to him so to speak, and he capitulated and decided to be ‘one of the girls’ so he can gain some respite.
I thought (with tongue firmly in cheek) that Bruce had
been turned into a woman due to his environment, but no, he later revealed that
this was a desire from childhood springing from deep within his psyche.
But, and this is a big but, is the power of his desire enough? What of a Black man who states that he has always felt that he was born in the wrong body and actually feels like a white man, would doctors and society run to his aide and grant him his wish? (I’m thinking of you Michael Jackson, RIP). What of the woman who always felt an affinity with dolphins and feels she should have been born a dolphin, should she be free to become who or what she wants to be?
Becoming a woman: Bruce with longer hair, feminine facial features and breasts
The medical, educational and political advancement of
societies today mean citizens across the world enjoy many freedoms, and being
free to ‘be who you want to be’ is a popular maxim. But the truth is that there
are also many chemically- imbalanced people, those with mental illnesses and
unstable people marred by previous trauma or whatever else, who come up with
all kinds of desires. I read recently of the girl who fell in love with a tree as a result of previous heartbreaks, and the man who felt so inspired by a demonic
character in a comic that he paid good money to distort his face to look like
the demon, horns and all. In days gone by, society didn’t give room for such
deviances of personality to flourish.
The flame of your outlandish desires was either extinguished prematurely by the thought of the shame or ostracisation your wants would cause,
the fact that there was no way, medically or otherwise to fulfil your longings
and the knowledge that such things were deviant at best, and wrong at worst.
But today, all things are equal. No one is wrong. There is a
website, community, advocacy group and even a cable TV documentary for every human pervasion you can think
of, from those who defecate on each other for sexual pleasure and grandmothers who perform sex acts online, to men
married to plastic dolls and lesbians who buy sperm from anonymous donors. Even
what is illegal is glamorised in the media, e.g. Oceans Eleven and the glamorisation of theft.
All things are acceptable, no one is wrong – God, morality
and common sense be damned.
So following his long-awaited televised interview with Diane
Sawyer, in which he spoke of his transition to becoming a woman (I didn’t watch
it), Bruce Jenner is a being hailed a hero, being called ‘brave’ for ‘living
his truth,’ and many across the (Western) world support him. Of course the
majority of people in Nigeria are appalled and shocked that such a thing is happening,
but the enlightened West could care less about the views of Africans who, to
them, remain under the yolk of religion and are tied down by archaic
traditions.
But as someone with one leg in both the Western and African
world, I’m firmly on the side of Nigerians here. Some things are just wrong.
Some things should remain unacceptable and should not be encouraged. Some things remain unnatural, no matter
the calibre of those going through it or how prosperous the societies that
promote it.
I believe that those that believe that they are gay,
transgender and all manner of unusual conditions are what they say they
are and feel what they say they feel, but I put it down to something along the lines of a hormonal imbalance or genetic abnormality at birth – the kind of
developmental malformation that results in physical deformities also resulting
in psychological deformities, or spiritual forces not of this world that the
non-religious know nothing about – forces of darkness that seek to destroy
humanity and torment some people; and finally, straight up psychosis on the same level as a man who
believes he is a poached egg. Some people, to put it crudely, are just crazy
and should not be given medication to further their crazy.
And the fact that many transgender people who do have
surgery to change their sex commit suicide afterwards to me indicates that
getting what we want isn’t the answer, and messing with nature can never lead
to true contentment. The intricacies involved in the formation of a foetus of
either sex is so complex and far-reaching , and being male or a female
encompasses the entire psychological, mental, social, spiritual, hormonal, biological, developmental,
cultural and personal as well as physical being, that attempting to ‘correct’ it later at
a superficial level can only lead to disaster.
Changing sex should be as wildly incomprehensible as changing brains or skin colour. Some things should be sacrosanct, some desires discouraged, and some wants suppressed. Not everything you feel is right, not every human desire is good or correct. That you’re in love with your brother or your mother (yes, I’ve read about these) doesn’t make it OK; the existence of a desire doesn’t legitimise it.
Some feelings should not be explored further. I believe there were many would-be transgender or homosexual people throughout history, but due to society's norms back then were able to successfully suppress or eradicate such desires for the greater good. Some thoughts only grow stronger with encouragement.
I will not attempt to diagnose Bruce Jenner. I actually like
the man, and thought him far more worthy of global adulation than any of his famous family, because he had actually achieved something worth celebrating. But there is something wrong with his desire to be a woman. And the
way (Western) liberal society rebukes anyone that even dares to call a spade a
spade and say that what Bruce is feeling is not kosher, and forcing everyone – at
least publicly anyway – into a faux acceptance of what is blatantly unnatural
is wrong, and a gross imbalance of freedom of speech.
We have lost all sense of shame, propriety and decency, and
nothing is allowed to be sacred anymore, to the detriment of our collective ethics
and stability. What we want – no matter how senseless – must be allowed, and to
hell with anyone who stands in our way. The enfant
terribles, the lewd and the crude, the mentally-imbalanced, the freaks and the
fetish, the dishonourable, the abominations, and the dangerously outlandish
have been allowed to set the moral temperature; the former outcasts have been
given the microphone and they’re spreading their gospel of anarchy.
That my father is now a woman is a thing wild jokes are made
of, and it cannot be easy on his children no matter how much everyone says
it’s OK. Deep down, we all sense that there’s something unpalatable about it;
it just doesn’t seem right.
Because it isn’t.